Why Two Recent Attempts to Rescue Constitutive Luck Do Not Work
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.3384/de-ethica.2001-8819.25845Keywords:
constitutive luck, modal luck, control luck, chancy luck, luck, moral luck, regress argument, luck egalitarianismAbstract
According to Rescher, luck is chancy, but constitution is not, and so constitutive luck is a contradiction in terms.
In this paper, I look at two recent attempts to controvert this argument. According to the first, constitution is not
chancy, but neither is moral luck, because moral luck is not a species of luck. According to the second, moral luck
is chancy, but constitution is too, because the comparative class is not the agent herself but rather the population
at large. I argue that neither of these attempts is successful. I begin by explaining the importance of constitutive
luck.
References
Anderson, Mark. 2019. “Moral Luck as Moral Lack of Control.” Southern Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 57, Issue 1:
-29.
Athanassoulis, Nafsika. 2005. Morality, Moral Luck and Responsibility. Palgrave Macmillan.
Athanassoulis, Nafsika. 2019. “Aristotle on Constitutive, Developmental, and Resultant Moral Luck.” In The
Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy and Psychology of Moral Luck (ed. Ian Church and Robert Hartman),
Routledge: 13-24.
Caruso, Gregg. 2019. “A Defense of the Luck Pincer.” Journal of Information Ethics, Vol. 28, No. 1: 51-72.
Coffman, E.J. 2014. “Strokes of Luck.” Metaphilosophy, Vol. 45, No. 4/5: 477-508.
Coffman, E.J. 2015. Luck. Palgrave Macmillan.
Coyne, Margaret. 1985. “Moral Luck?” The Journal of Value Inquiry, Vol. 19: 319-325.
Enoch, David. 2010. “Moral Luck and the Law.” Philosophy Compass, Vol. 5, Issue 1: 42-54.
Enoch, David and Marmor, Andrei. 2007. “The Case Against Moral Luck.” Law and Philosophy, Vol. 26:
-436.
Feinberg, Joel. 1962. “Problematic Responsibility in Law and Morals.” The Philosophical Review, Vol. 71, No. 3:
-351.
Greco, John. 1995. “A Second Paradox Concerning Moral Luck.” Metaphilosophy, Vol. 26, No. 1/2: 81-96.
Hales, Steven. 2015. “A Problem for Moral Luck.” Philosophical Studies, Vol. 172, No. 9: 2385-2403.
Hartman, Robert. 2017. In Defense of Moral Luck. Routledge.
Hartman, Robert. 2019. “Accepting Moral Luck.” In The Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy and Psychology
of Moral Luck (ed. Ian Church and Robert Hartman), Routledge: 227-238.
Holden, Constance. 1987. “The Genetics of Personality.” Science Vol. 237, Issue 4815: 598-601. https://
doi.org/10.1126/science.3603041
Kahn, Samuel. 2021. “Kant’s Philosophy of Moral Luck.” Sophia, Vol. 60: 365-387.
Lackey, Jennifer. 2008. “What Luck is Not.” Australasian Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 86, Issue 2: 255-267.
Latus, Andrew. 2000. “Moral and Epistemic Luck.” Journal of Philosophical Research, Vol. 25: 149-172.
Latus, Andrew. 2003. “Constitutive Luck.” Metaphilosophy, Vol. 34, No. 4: 460-475.
Latus, Andrew. 2019. “Nagel and Williams on Moral Luck.” In The Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy and
Psychology of Moral Luck (ed. Ian Church and Robert Hartman), Routledge: 105-112.
Levy, Neil. 2009. “What, and Where, Luck Is.” Australasian Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 87, No. 3: 489-497.
Levy, Neil. 2011. Hard Luck. Oxford University Press.
Rescher, Nicholas. 1993. “Moral Luck.” In Moral Luck (ed. Daniel Statman), State University of New York Press:
-166.
Rescher, Nicholas. 1995. Luck. University of Pittsburgh Press.
Richards, Norvin. 1993. “Luck and Desert.” In Moral Luck (ed. Daniel Statman), State University of New York
Press: 167-180.
Riggs, Wayne. 2009. “Luck, Knowledge, and Control.” In Epistemic Value (ed.s Adrian Haddock, Alan Millar,
and Duncan Pritchard), Oxford University Press: 204-223.
Riggs, Wayne. 2019. “The Lack of Control Account of Luck.” In The Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy and
Psychology of Moral Luck (ed. Ian Church and Robert Hartman), Routledge: 125-135.
Rosebury, Brian. 1995. “Moral Responsibility and “Moral Luck”.” The Philosophical Review, Vol. 104, No. 4:
-524.
Rosell, Sergi. 2015. “Moral Luck and True Desert.” In Agency, Freedom, and Moral Responsibility (ed. Andre
Buckareff, Carlos Moya, and Sergi Rosell), Palgrave Macmillan: 116-133.
Statman, Daniel. 1991. “Moral and Epistemic Luck.” Ratio, Vol. 4, Issue 2: 146-156.
Statman, Daniel. 2019. “The Definition of “Luck” and the Problem of Moral Luck.” In The Routledge Handbook
of the Philosophy and Psychology of Moral Luck (ed. Ian Church and Robert Hartman), Routledge: 195-205.
Thomson, Judith. 1989. “Morality and Bad Luck.” Metaphilosophy, Vol. 20, No. 3/4: 203-221.
Thomson, Judith. 1993. “Morality and Bad Luck.” In Moral Luck (ed. Daniel Statman), State University of New
York Press: 195-216.
Whittington, Lee John. 2014. “Getting Moral Luck Right.” Metaphilosophy, Vol. 45, No. 4/5: 654–667.
Williams, Bernard. 1982. Moral Luck. Cambridge University Press.
Williams, Bernard. 1993. “Postscript.” In Moral Luck (ed. Daniel Statman), State University of New York Press:
-258.
Zimmerman, Michael. 1987. “Luck and Responsibility.” Ethics, Vol. 97, No. 2: 374-386.
Zimmerman, Michael. 1993. “Luck and Moral Responsibility.” In Moral Luck (ed. Daniel Statman), State
University of New York Press: 217-234.
Zimmerman, Michael. 2002. “Taking Luck Seriously.” The Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 99, No. 11: 553-576.
Zimmerman, Michael. 2006. “Moral luck.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 36, No. 4: 585-608.
Zimmerman, Michael. 2019. “Denying Moral Luck.” In The Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy and
Psychology of Moral Luck (ed. Ian Church and Robert Hartman), Routledge: 216-226.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Samuel Kahn
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
